Oct 21, 2019 | Prime announcements

Weekly Market Update (Issue 570) – 21 October 2019

Securities mentioned this week

  • IOOF (IFL), Challenger (CGF), Afterpay (APT), Boral (BLD), BHP (BHP), Rio Tinto (RIO)

Key market themes

Trade tensions >

  • It was a quiet week on the trade front albeit the Chinese government have said they would expect the US to roll back existing tariffs for them to be able to commit to the type of agricultural buying quantities President Trump had alluded to at last week’s supposed agreement.
  • This issue will again likely escalate as we get closer to the next planned tariff implementation date by the United States, being the 15th of December 2019.

Economic data released

Australian September employment figures remained surprisingly strong, with 26,200 new full-time jobs created and an unemployment rate of 5.2%.

The data continues to defy the weakness seen in job advertising – skilled vacancies are -6% on last year and the wider ANZ job advertisement figures are down -11% on 2018.

Early October manufacturing data in the US seems to have stabilised with the Empire (New York) manufacturing sentiment bouncing modestly this month

Chinese Q3 GDP grew at an annualised rate of 6% which is the lowest figure since the data series started nearly 30 years ago in 1992.

China’s economy continues to soften as the impact of US tariff’s on US$360bn of Chinese exports to the US weighs, though we would expect to see continued, measured fiscal and monetary stimulus afforded by authorities to mitigate the significant slowing.

US housing sector trends remain positive with the October NAHB Housing Market Index jumping again in October and just shy of the record optimism we saw in the sector back at the start of 2018.

Falling mortgage interest rates continue to generate strong homebuilding activity and September Housing Starts and Building Permits rare up +12% and +8% on the previous year respectively.

Observations from the past week

IOOF (IFL) confirmed our expectations and announced last week that they were set to complete the ANZ Wealth transaction and at discounted price.

  • Having announced the planned acquisition of ANZ Wealth for $975m as far back as November 2017, the two groups finally confirmed the transaction would go ahead last week, and at a nicely discounted price of $825m.
  • IFL’s shares jumped +18% on the week and the stock is now up over 40% for the year-to-date.
  • We think the shares will settle above $8+ before the year ends now that the corporate uncertainty is beginning to lift.
  • In a highly fragmented industry where the landscape is awash with the opportunity to consolidate and rationalize cost, we think 11x 2021 earnings is simply way too cheap for a company with the industry positioning and strength of cashflows that IFL has.
  • This stock will continue higher in the years ahead.

Challenger (CGF) reported a resilient first quarter in the face of falling interest rates and the stock bounced accordingly.

  • The stock bounced over +10% last week after surprising investors with strong net annuity sales growth in the Q1, albeit via the lower margin wholesale channel and via higher risk guaranteed income products.
  • The company re-affirmed their 2020 normalized net profit target of $500-550m.
  • The market response demonstrates that investor expectations are very low for CGF and that should we see an improvement in the domestic retail channel as the post-Royal Commission advice disruption settles, then CGF shares can go a lot higher.

Afterpay (APT) shares were one of the worst performers during the week, falling -17% after UBS initiated coverage of the stock with a contrarian SELL rating.

  • The prevailing issue raised in the report was APT’s ‘no surcharge’ clause which prevents merchants from passing on the cost of APT’s platform back to the consumer in a manner such as that done by the likes of Mastercard, American Express and Visa.
  • The suggestion being that if merchants were in the position to do this, potentially the Afterpay platform might lose its appeal with customers.
  • The RBA announced last week it would conduct a review into the ‘buy now, pay later’ sector to determine whether retailers required help recovering the costs.
  • We think its quite likely that this issue will prove to be as impactful on APT as investor fears were over the Senate and ACCC reviews of predatory lending and the more recent AUSTRAC investigation of APT over money laundering issues.
  • Our recommended positions on APT have been significantly reduced in recent months as we felt the stock was beginning to price in much of the blue-sky opportunity, however we remain committed to the long-term growth story and retain a recommended holding.
  • Weakness like that seen last week opens up the opportunity in time to potentially add to holdings again.

Boral (BLD) was the subject of M&A chatter during the week with The Australian publishing an article suggesting US private equity giant, Lone Star, could be considering a bid for the company.

  • The stock bounced modestly but not with the vigour that might imply investors thought a bid was soon to arrive.
  • That said, BLD’s business is widely disparate and has the makings of a break-up for any financial or corporate bidder willing to undertake the task.
  • We think the underlying demand picture for US residential construction is strong and that expectations on BLD earnings are now quite low, which makes us feel like the risk/reward offered by BLD shares at current levels under $5 look particularly attractive.

What’s interesting?

We note, with some modest trepidation, that though the Australian share-market is +18% year-to-date and within 3% of its high, that the Australian mining sector has not only foregone its sector leadership, but in fact underperformed quite materially over the last 3 months.

As the chart below shows, the Australian mining sector does a very good job of pre-empting the performance of the wider market.

As the leading edge of the market in a cyclical earnings sense, investor appetite for miners tends to offer an early look at future risk appetite across the wider market.

In red is the ‘relative’ performance of the Australian material sector against the ASX200 benchmark, and the white line is the ASX200 share price index lagged by 6 weeks.

The underperformance of Australian miners since Q2 seems set to presage consolidation in the wider market in the weeks and months ahead.

The slowing Chinese economy is the main culprit for recent weakening in iron ore prices from their July highs at $110/ton to todays level at a touch over $80/ton.

BHP (BHP) and Rio Tinto (RIO) share prices have underperformed the market by almost -20% since their peak in April, although Fortescue (FMG) has fared marginally better.

Mining sector relative performance (in red) regularly leads the wider ASX200 index (in white)

Looking ahead

  • Monday – N/A
  • Tuesday – N/A
  • Wednesday – AU US Richmond Fed manufacturing (Oct)
  • Thursday – AU CBA Manufacturing & Service sector PMI’s (Oct), US Markit Manufacturing & Service sector PMI’s (Oct)
  • Friday – US Michigan Consumer sentiment (Oct)

Major corporate results in the US this week will come from Microsoft (MSFT) and Amazon (AMZN), and then the following week will see Apple (AAPL), Google (GOOG) and Facebook (FB) all report.

In Australia, the major banks and Pendal (PDL) will report September year end results in 2-3 weeks.



The information in this article contains general advice and is provided by Primestock Securities Ltd AFSL 239180. That advice has been prepared without taking your personal objectives, financial situation or needs into account. Before acting on this general advice, you should consider the appropriateness of it having regard to your personal objectives, financial situation and needs. You should obtain and read the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) before making any decision to acquire any financial product referred to in this article. Please refer to the FSG for contact information and information about remuneration and associations with product issuers. This information should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice, and we encourage you to seek specific advice from your professional adviser before making a decision on the matters discussed in this article. Information in this article is current at the date of this article, and we have no obligation to update or revise it as a result of any change in events, circumstances or conditions upon which it is based.


A unique and personal service approach and support for all your business advisory and personal wealth management needs

Request a consultation

A unique and personal service approach to support all your business advisory and personal wealth management needs.

Request a consultation